The dean creates a Hunger Games-style competition for admission into a History of Ice Cream class--the final class Jeff needs to graduate. Meanwhile, a fear of graduation causes Abed to retreat to his happy place.
At the Inspector SpaceTime Convention, Abed finds a new "soulmate," Jeff discovers he looks like one of the show's villains, Shirley and Pierce join a focus group, and Annie pretends to be Jeff's husband.
Dean Pelton and Annie try to land a "whale" student while Jeff is assigned to keep Pierce occupied. Meanwhile, Troy and Shirley take a physical education education course, and Abed creates a fraternity to annoy the dean.